2017 Mock Caldecott Results

 

(Look here for the methodology used: carolsimonlevin.blogspot.com/2015/01/mock-caldecott-committee-be-judge.html )

Mock Caldecott Results Bedminster School – approximately 300 students – 5 groups

Totals:
Are We There Yet? by Dan Sandat -- Gold (3), Silver (1)
Maybe Something Beautiful illustrated by Rafael Lopez-- Gold (1), Silver (2)
They All Saw a Cat  by Brendon Wenzel --  Silver (3)
The Night Gardener by the Fan Brothers-- Silver (3)
Return  by Aaron Becker -- Gold (1) Silver (1)
The Airport Book by Lisa Brown – Silver (2)
Du Iz Tak by Carson Ellis – Gold (1)
Ada’s Violin illustrated by Sally Wern Comport – Silver (1)
We Found a Hat by Jon Klassen – Silver (1)

Individual group results:
Valentine, Hofman, & Hogan -- Winner(tie):

Honors:

3rd Grade --  Winner:

Honors:

Kindergarten -- Winner:

Honors:

Lovejoy & McFarland -- Winner:

Honors:

4th Grade -- Winner:

Honors:

Here are the other books the kids considered:

Raw Numbers (Preliminary votes each book received at Bedminster School – I saw 5 classes, if there is a number in parens, it means there were less than 5 bookmarks found)

Ada’s Violin  53
The Airport Book   69
Are We There Yet?   75 
Before Morning   66
The Cat from Hunger Mountain  46
Daniel Finds a Poem  40
Du Iz Tak?   38
Freedom in Congo Square   21 (4)
I am a Story   62
Maybe Something Beautiful   55
The Night Gardener   86 (4)
The Perfect Tree  70
Return   56
School’s First Day of School  62 (4)
Steamboat School     31
There is a Tribe of Kids    62
They All Saw a Cat    85
This is Not a Picture Book   60
Thunder Boy Jr.   44
The Uncorker of Ocean Bottles   43
We Found a Hat   55

 

Bridgewater Library 2017 Mock Caldecott Winner:

Honor Books:

1/2017